What's Cooking Cafe Menu
At What's Cooking Cafe Menu, you'll find a delightful variety of dishes designed to satisfy every craving. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast, a light lunch, or a comforting dinner, there's something here for everyone. Located at 139 2nd St NW in New Philadelphia, OH, this charming café takes pride in serving up fresh, locally sourced ingredients in every dish. The menu offers an array of options from savory sandwiches to mouthwatering entrees, each crafted to bring out the best in classic comfort food. With a welcoming atmosphere, it's the perfect spot to enjoy a meal with friends, family, or even a quick bite on your own. Explore the diverse flavors and find your new favorite dish at What's Cooking Cafe Menu.
1 / 4
Desserts
Apple Pie Cheesecake Slice
Cupcake Of The Day
Choose your flavor! Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Jumbo Cinnamon Roll Cookies
Pricing incentive: due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% admin fee added. this was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. we appreciate your understanding thank you
Snickerdoodle Cookie
Allergy Warning** Contains Peanut butter** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
16oz Strawberry Rhubarb Jelly
By the slice
Caramel Banana Cream Pie Trifle
Pumpkin Roll
By the slice
9" Banana Cream Pie
By the slice
Build Your Own Christmas Cookie Box
Pick as many cookies as you want, they're priced per cookie.
GF Pumpkin Cookie
Half Dozen Pumpkin Cookies
GF Lemon Cookie
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Peppermint Cheesecake
Jumbo Cinnamon Rolls
Pricing incentive: due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% admin fee added. this was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. we appreciate your understanding thank you
Christmas Tree Cake
By the slice
Snickerdoodle Latte Cheesecake
HOHO Cake Roll
By the slice
Christmas Cutout
Pricing incentive: due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% admin fee added. this was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. we appreciate your understanding thank you
Cake Pop
Pumpkin Cookies
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Breadi Loaf
Gluten free brownie
Jumbo Lemon Crinkle Cookies
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Peppermint Brownie
Pricing incentive: due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% admin fee added. this was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. we appreciate your understanding thank you
Sandwiches & Wraps
Pressed Turkey Ranch Club Wrap
Oven roasted turkey, cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes & ranch dressing ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Garden Veggie Wrap
Fresh Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Onions, Mixed Greens, Bell Pepper, Edamame, Broccoli, Cauliflower, & Roasted Garlic Aioli ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Shredded Ham Sandwich
House Made Shredded Ham, Provolone Cheese & Hawaiian Aioli, Served on a Pretzel Bun ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Southwest Chicken Wrap
Shredded Chicken, Mixed Greens, Cheddar Cheese, Tomatoes, Black Beans, Corn, Onions, & Spicy Ranch ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Drinks
Short Blend-A-Ccino
caramel, mint, mocha, hazelnut, vanilla, or skinny vanilla Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Fountain Drink
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Assorted Hot Tea
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Tall House Coffee
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Tall-Flavor Of The Day
**Pumpkin ** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Chocolate Milk
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Flavored Café' Latte
Caramel, Mint, Mocha, Hazelnut, Vanilla, or Skinny Vanilla Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Hand Shaken Ice Tea
20 oz Sweet or Unsweet If you want flavors: Raspberry or Peach Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Large House Coffee
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Tall Blend-A-Ccino
Caramel, Mint. Mocha, Hazelnut, Vanilla, or Skinny Vanilla Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Regular Iced Coffee
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Espresso
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Hot Chocolate
20 oz Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Lg Espresso
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Regular - Flavor Of The Day
**Vanilla Chai Spice** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Milk
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Tall Iced Coffee
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Sparkling Ice
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Bottled Water
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Pumpkin Iced Coffee
Gatorade
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Cappuccino
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Chai Latte
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Smoothie
16oz Mango, Strawberry Banana, Blueberry Pomegranate Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Café Latte
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Sides
Mini Orzo Veggie Salad
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Mini Creamy Mac And Cheese
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Mini Beets & Egg
Mini Cheesy Potato
Pricing incentive: due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% admin fee added. this was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. we appreciate your understanding thank you
Full Beets & Eggs
Full Orzo Veggie Salad
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Full Cheesy Potato
Pricing incentive: due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% admin fee added. this was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. we appreciate your understanding thank you
Full Creamy Mac And Cheese
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Mini Fresh Fruit
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Full Fresh Fruit
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Daily Specials
PICK 2 Turkey & Apple Panini
PICK 2 Turkey Bacon Sandwich With Avocado Ranch
FULL SIZE- Christmas Salad With Cranberry Vinaigrette
Full size Only If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Cornbread Chili Bowl
Choice of side.
Buffalo Chicken Panini
Choice of side.
Meatloaf Sandwich
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!
Spinach & Artichoke Quiche
Pricing incentive: due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% admin fee added. this was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. we appreciate your understanding thank you
Specialty Drinks
Hot Coco Bomb With Steamed Milk
White Chocolate, Chocolate
Christmas Hot Coco Bombs
Chocolate Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Salads
Blue Cheese Wedge
Crisp Iceberg Wedge Topped with Tomatoes, Onions, Bacon, Hard Boiled Eggs, Blue Cheese Dressing, & Balsamic Reduction ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
House Side Salad
Mixed Greens, Cucumbers, Cheddar Cheese, & Croutons ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
16oz Garden Salad
Homegrown veggie salad
Veggie & Cheese Salad- Half
Mixed Greens, Cheddar Cheese, Edamame, Broccoli, Cauliflower, Bell Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Red Onion & Red Wine Vinaigrette ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Taco Salad - Full
Mixed Greens, Taco Meat, Cheddar Cheese, Tomatoes, Edamame, Cucumbers, Bell Pepper, Onion, Crispy Tortilla Strips, & Spicy Ranch ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Veggie & Cheese Salad- Full
Mixed Greens, Cheddar Cheese, Edamame, Broccoli, Cauliflower, Bell Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Red Onion & Red Wine Vinaigrette ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Chicken & Pear- Half
Mixed Greens, Shredded Chicken, Sliced Pears, Glazed Pecans, Craisins, White Cheddar Cheese, & Honey Rosemary Vinaigrette ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Taco Salad - Half
Mixed Greens, Taco Meat, Cheddar Cheese, Tomatoes, Edamame, Cucumbers, Bell Pepper, Onion, Crispy Tortilla Strips, & Spicy Ranch ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Chicken & Pear- Full
Mixed Greens, Shredded Chicken, Sliced Pears, Glazed Pecans, Craisins, White Cheddar Cheese, & Honey Rosemary Vinaigrette ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Panini
The Melt
Multi-Grain Bread with Swiss & Cheddar Cheese ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Turkey Reuben
Oven roasted turkey, tangy sauerkraut, swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing on marble bread ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Italian Panini
Salami, Ham, Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, Spinach, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber, & Sundried Tomato Aioli on Italian Bread ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Mushroom Bacon Panini
Bacon Crumbles, White Cheddar Cheese, Sautéed Mushrooms, Spinach, Tomatoes, & Roasted Garlic Aioli on Marble Bread ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Soups
Cup Of Soup
Please Select Choice Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Quart Of Soup
Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Bowl Of Soup
Please Select Choice Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Kids Meal
Kids Meal- PB & J Sandwich
This comes with Apple Sauce and Fruit Snacks Enjoy :) ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Kids Meal- Half Grilled Cheese
this comes with Apple Sauce & Fruit Snacks Enjoy :) ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
PICK TWO! Choose First Item:
Pick 2- Bacon Mushroom Panini (Half)
Bacon crumbles, white cheddar cheese, sautéed mushrooms, spinach tomatoes and roasted garlic aioli on marble bread Make sure to pick your 2nd option. ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Pick 2- Turkey Rueben (Half)
oven Roasted turkey, tangy sauerkraut, swiss cheese, and thousand island dressing Make sure to click your second Pick. ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Pick 2- Italian Panini (Half)
Salami, ham , pepperoni, provolone cheese, spinach, tomato, onion ,cucumber, and homemade basil sundried tomato aioli on Italian bread Make sure to click your 2nd Pick! ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Pick 2- The Melt (Half)
multi-grain bread, swiss cheese, and cheddar cheese Make sure to Pick your 2nd option. ***If you want extra dressing you need to click that under extra dressings, please don't just type in the notes or you wont receive any, thank you!*** Pricing Incentive: Due to rising bank fees all non-cash payments have a 3.50% ADMIN FEE added. This was automatically added to the pricing of the items listed. We appreciate your understanding! Thank You!!
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available. 📞 +1 330-364-2444